Mr. and Mrs. Potato Head Cookies

potato head smm

Mr. and Mrs. Potato Head Cookies


Who else is super excited to watch the new Toy Story 4 movie? Well these cookies are the perfect little treat to enjoy while you wait for the newest Toy Story movie to hit theaters. Even if you are not a big Toy Story fan you can still enjoy these super fun Mr. and Mrs. Potato Head Cookies for any occasion. 

What You Will Need:

  • Your favorite sugar cookie cutout recipe, prepared
  • Your favorite frosting recipe (white)
  • Black Fondant
  • Pink Fondant
  • Orange Fondant
  • Red Fondant
  • Yellow Fondant
  • Brown Food Coloring Gel
  • Yellow Food Coloring Gel
  • Candy Eyes (or use fondant)
  • Candy Moustaches (or use fondant)


  • Roll out your sugar cookies, and use an egg shaped cookie cutter to cut out as many cookies as you can.
  • Bake according to the recipe, and set aside to cool completely.
  • Place your frosting in a bowl, and add in brown and yellow food coloring until you get a light brown color.
  • Frost the cookies evenly, avoiding the edges.
  • Place two eyes about ⅓ of the way down on each cookie.
  • Roll a piece of pink fondant into a 3D triangle for Mrs. Potato Head cookies. And roll a piece of orange fondant into a 3D triangle for Mr. Potato Head cookies.
  • Flatten a small piece of pink fondant into a circle, and cut in half. Round out the edges, and place beside the eyes for ears.
  • Roll very small balls of yellow fondant, and place on Mrs. Potato Head for earrings.
  • Place a moustache candy between Mr. Potato Head’s nose and mouth.
  • Take a medium sized piece of red fondant, and roll like a snake. Shape into mouths for Mr. and Mrs. Potato Head.
  • Place a thin sheet of black fondant behind Mr. Potato Head’s mouth if you would like it to be open.
  • Roll thin pieces of black fondant, and place them above the eyes for eyebrows.
  • Roll a large piece of black fondant into a sheet, and shape it into a hat for Mr. Potato Head cookies.
  • Frost the very top of Mrs. Potato Head cookies with remaining white frosting to make her hat.
  • Roll five small balls of orange fondant, and place them into the shape of a flower, and add it to the center of Mrs. Potato Head’s hat.
  • Enjoy!










This post contains affiliate links

Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, Disclosure, Disclaimer